This list was compiled by Whereyoueat Staff Members which went out on a pizza run after following much advice from neighborhood friends & co-workers.
This list does not neccessarily require a restaurant to be reviewed, as it is impossible to write a legit review for a simple takeaway.

Deninos: Voted best tasting pizza for longest time: http://whereyoueat.com/NY/StatenIsland/10302/DineIn/Deninos.html

Joe & Pats: Voted best thing crust pizza:
http://whereyoueat.com/NY/StatenIsland/10314/Both/JoePats.html

Costco Pizza “Fresh, Fully Loaded”: Voted best overstuffed Pizza:  No menu, but give it a try…

Grandma’s Original: Voted best Grandmas Slice:
http://whereyoueat.com/NY/StatenIsland/10305/TakeOut/GrandmasOriginal.html

Village Maria Pizzeria: Voted: Longest Running Famous Calamari Slice – Best Tasting
http://whereyoueat.com/NY/StatenIsland/10308/TakeOut/VillageMaria.html
There is review of this slice under Restaurant Reviews.