The firehouse gets a new restaurant next door at 1195 Castleton Avenue, and the restaurant has a bold mission statement of serving the Best Gyro in NY. It is Staten Island’s only Pork Rotisserie Gyro, other spots use Lamb, Beef and Chicken Shawarma but Dimitri’s Gyro Joint serves Pork.
View the full Menus and Photos of Dimitri’s Gyro Joint
The restaurant replaces Mi Casa, the Spanish buffet style restaurant that sat here for a few years and keeps a similar comfortable open dining room inside along with cakes and warm food platters at the buffet counter. The restaurant is serving local Greek Favorites, Spanakopita, Dolmades, Wraps, Pita Sandwiches are said to be overstuffed and for $7.50 come with French Fries. American Grill, Platters and Greek Specialty Dinners such as Moussaka and Pastitsio are on the menu.